17 May 2014

The swallow




Some years ago, Kim McCone1 noticed the striking similarity between the Insular Celtic (Old Irish fannall, Welsh gwennol) and the Basque (enara, ain(h)ara, etc.2) words for 'swallow', thus reconstructing a Celtic protoform *wannālā/*wennālā. It also becomes apparent that the Basque word must be a loanword from Celtic, although with an unusual loss of *w-, which we would expect to surface either as b- or m-3 in Basque.

For the Celtic word, Ranko Matasović3 devises an IE etymology from *wes-r-/-n- 'spring' plus the adjectival suffix -ālā, implying a semantic development from 'messenger of spring'. As -sn- regularly gives Celtic -nn-, we also need to assume the variant *wannālā arose from *wennālā from vowel harmonization. However, this proposal has been objected by some scholars, namely David Stifter4, who thinks both Celtic and Basque are loanwords from a substrate language, presumably non-IE.

Although I also disagree with Matasović, I think an IE etymology (although not a native Celtic one) is still possible from the root  *wand-/*wend- 'to weave, to twist', with -nd- > -nn- in an unidentified IE language. As swallows are seasonal birds, semantics would be parallel to Old High German wantalōn 'to be back and forth; to change' > German wandeln.


On the other hand, French vanneau 'lapwing' (linked by some scholars to the Celtic word) derives from Late Latin *vannellus, a diminutive form of vannus 'winnowing basket', which I'd adscribe to the above etymology. The Latin word was borrowed into Old English fann 'winnowing basket' > English fan5.
_____________________________________
1 K. McCone (2005): 'Mögliche nicht-indogermanische Elemente in den keltischen Sprachen und einige frühe Entlehnungen aus indogermanischen Nachbarsprachen', in G. Meiser and O. Hackstein (eds.), Sprachkontact und Sprachwandel. Akten der XI. Fachtagung der Indogermanischen Gesellschaft, 17.-23. September 2000, Halle an der Saale, Wiesbaden, p. 395-435.
2 Variants include ainhara (L), ainhera (LN), aiñara (LN), aiñera (LN), añhá(r)a (Z), añhé(r)a (Z), enara (B,*A, G, HN), txenara (G), enada (B, G, HN,*L), txenada (G), einhara (L), ernara (B), enere (HN), inara (HN), iñara (HN), inhara (L, LN), iñare (Aezk), inhade (L), iñar (R, S), aiñari (S), elae (*B), elai (B, G), alae (B), alai (B, G), añai (R), which refer to either 'barn swallow (Hirundo rustica)' or (less frequently) to 'common swift (Apus apus)'. There's also the compund 
gau-enada (*L), gabenara (HN), gau-inhara (*L), gau-iñara (HN, Bazt), maiñari (R) 'bat', from gau 'night'.
3 R. Matasović (2009): Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic, p. 416-417.
54 D. Stifter (2010): The Invisible Third: The Basque and Celtic Words for 'Swallow', Ériu 60, p. 145-157.
5 Other words for 'fan' in Romance languages such as Spanish abanico, Catalan vano, are ultimately derived from vannus.

09 February 2014

The rose



Avestan varəda, New Persian gul 'rose' < Iranian *wr̥da- is a Wanderwort which spread to Armenian vard, Aramaic wardāˀ, Arabic ward1. Beekes considers Greek rhódon (Aeolic bródon) 'rose' < *wródon to be "certainly borrowed from the East", but he forgets to explain the Greek vocalism (ro instead of the expected ar/ra).

In my opinion, the Greek word would be a substrate borrowing from a reflex of *wr̥d-o- in a language where  r̥ > ro as in like Holzer's "Temematic"2. This protoform is the source of Germanic *wurθ-/*wurd- 'sweet briar (Rosa rubiginosa)' and Italic *ruθo- 'bramble (Rubus fruticosus)' > Latin rubus.
 
On the other hand, dialectal Italian (Tuscan) rasa, ràzina, razzola 'bramble' would be derived from Etruscan *raθia (glossed as radia by classical authors) < *rad-ja3. Also according to my amateur colleague Douglas Kilday, Latin rosa 'rose'4 would be a loanword from Etruscan *ruθia through the intermediation of Sabine *rodja.

Also Kartvelian *bardzg- 'thorns, thorny plant', *burdzg(a)/burtʃx
- 'bristle' would descend from an earlier protoform *bardj-/*burdj- 'thorn', where the cluster *dzg would derive from a patalized dental stop *dj, according to the correspondences proposed by Bomhard5.
________________________________
1 R.S.P. Beekes (2010): Etymological Dictionary of Greek, p. 1289-1290.
2 G. Holzer (1989): Entlehnungen aus einer bisher unbekannten indogermanischen Sprach in Urslavischen und Urbalistischen. See also F. Kortland (2010): An Indo-European substratum in Slavic?, in Studies in Germanic, Indo-European and Indo-Uralic, p. 73-81.
3 This etymology would also explain Latin radius '(pointed) stick; light beam; wheel spoke' as a loanword from Etruscan.
4 Which Beekes considers to be "probably borrowed from Greek, but the details are unclear". Good gracious!
5
 A. Bomhard (2008): Reconstructing Proto-Nostratic, vol. 2, p. 237-243.

18 November 2013

Paleo-Balkanic *mendjo- 'foal' (updated)


Albanian mëz, mâz, Romanian mînz (a Dacian substrate loanword) 'foal' derive from a Paleo-Balkanic1 protoform *mendjo-2 related to Gaulish mandu-, borrowed in turn into Latin mannus3. Also related are Basque mando 'mule' (dialectally also 'sterile animal or woman'), presumably a Celtic loanword, as well as dialectal High German (Tirol) Manz, Menz 'sterile cow'4 and Italian manzo 'ox'5. 

Basque idi 'ox' can also be derived from this etymoloy, assuming the following changes (not necessarily in that order): 1) loss of m-, 2) end > id, 3) -o > -i6.

Probably also belong here Sanskrit mandurā 'stable for horses', mandira- 'dwelling, house' and Greek mándra 'pen, stable'. In my opinion, we're dealing with a Wanderwort *mand- of ultimate Altaic origin: Tungusic *manda-ksa 'Eurasian elk (Alces alces)', Mongolian *mandʒi 'male elk' and Turkic *botu 'young of camel'  (EDAL 1253).
_____________________________
1 Certainly not IE-native as thought by Mallory-Adams. See J.P. Mallory & D.Q. Adams (2006): The Oxford Introduction to PIE and the PIE World, p. 142.
2 T. Gaitzsch (2010): Das Pferd bei den Indogermanen: Sprachliche, kulturelle und archäologische Aspekte, p. 263-264.
3 X. Delamarre (2008): Dictionnaire de la langue gauloise, p. 214.
4 J. Pokorný (1958): Indogermanisches Etymologisches Wörterbuch, p. 729.
5 Possibly a Messapic loanword, cfr. Menzana, a divinity to whom horses were offered.
6 In sharp contrast with more recent loanwords, the native core of Basque underwent so many phonetic changes, up to the point of making it hardly recognizable.

13 November 2013

The ancient Basque homeland (updated)


According to most specialists, the area located between the Garonne river and the Pyrenees, ancient Aquitaine and modern Gascony, is the homeland of the ancient Basques. There we find a high density of Gascon toponyms in -òs, which extends to Basque -oz(e), -otz(e) and Navarro-Aragonese -ués on the other side of the Pyrenees1.

This toponymic element derives from Celtic *ouxsV- 'high' (Old Irish úais, Cornish a-ūch)2, whose superlative *uxsV-(s)amo- 'the highest' can be found in Middle Welsh uchaf, and the femenine *uxsV-(s)amā in Gaulish Uxisama (modern Oisème), Uxama3 and Celtiberian Usama (modern Osma). On the other hand, the former proposal of the Spanish linguist Ramón Menéndez Pidal, who linked the toponymic element to Basque otz 'cold' (itself from Celtic *ouxtu-4), can be dismissed.

The same lexeme would also be part of the Aquitanian anthroponym element Andos(s)-, Andox- (Latinized as Andossus, Andoxus) 'lord'5, whose first member would be the Gaulish intensive prefix and- 'very'. In my opinion, this evidence, together with loanwords such as gizon 'man' < Gaulish gdonio-, would indicate a Celtic substrate in Paleo-Basque whose existence hasn't been yet discovered by academic Vascologists.
________________________
1 G. Rohlfs (1970): Le Gascon. Études de phylologie pyrénénne. p. 29-33.
2 R. Matasović (2009): Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic, p. 303.
3 X. Delamarre (2008): Dictionnaire de la langue gauloise, p. 329.
4 R. Matasović, op. cit., p. 304.
5 Replaced in modern Basque by jaun < *e-aun, presumably a fossilized participle 'elevated'. 

Man and dog (updated)

Uralic *koje 'man, person' is a remnant of a Borean word which spread as a Wanderwort into East Caucasian *χχHweje (NCED 26) and Tibeto-Burman *qhʷi:j 'dog'1. The suffixed variant  *koj(e)-ra  > Uralic *kojra 'male (dog, man)' would correspond to East Caucasian *χχHwej-rV 'dog' (oblique stem) and Kartvelian (Svan) xwir- 'male (dog)'. 

On the other hand, Sinitic *khʷi:-n 'dog' borrowed into IE *k´(u)wo:n (a cultural loanword whose direction has been often reversed by Indo-Europeanists2) would be derived from the same lexem with a different suffix. 

Unfortunately, most macro-comparativists are unable to differentiate between borrowed and inherited lexicon3, as they blindly apply the comparative method coined in the 19th by Neogrammarians, which assumes common inheritance from a single source, represented by the genealogical tree model. By applying it to some hundreds of words, this process ultimately leads to the reconstruction of non-existent macro-families whose chronology is shallower (typically 2-3 times) than the actual ones. 
______________________ 
1 For which Starostin reconstructed a Sino-Caucasian etymology.
2 T.V. Gamkrelidze & V.V. Ivanov (1995): Indo-European and the Indo-Europeans, p. 507. 
3 Generally, the lesser the semantic latitude, the likelier we're dealing with a Wanderwort, as it's often the case with names of domesticated animals.

19 September 2013

Spanish jara 'rock rose; low bushes' (updated)


Spanish jara (old xara) 'rock rose (Cistus); low bushes' designates several species of perennial shrubs common in the Mediterranean area, especially Cistus ladanifer, which in other Hispano-Romance languages and Moroccan Arabic are designated with derivatives of Hispanic Latin stip(p)a.

The Spanish word has correspondences in Portuguese (en)xara 'low bushes' and Galician xara, Basque xara, txara, zara 'rock rose', and it's a borrowing from Hispano-Arabic ʃáʕra (Classical ʃaʕrāʔ) 'thicket, wood'1. The Arabic word is in turn related to ʃaʕār- 'thick and interlaced trees which give shadow in summer and shelter in winter; vegetation', ʃaʕīr 'barley' < Semitic *ɬaʕVr- 'barley; grass, straw' (ND 2219), contaminated with ʃaʕr- 'hair' < Semitic *ɬaʕr- 'hair' (ND 2220).
__________________________________
1 F. Corriente (2003): Diccionario de arabismos y voces afines en iberorromance, p. 307-308.

17 September 2013

New Vasco-romance blog

Dear readers,

I've created a new Vasco-romance blog for a smoother communication with my potential readers about Romance etymologies (including borrowings into Basque). To achieve this goal, I'm going to write in Spanish, although occasionally I'd employ Catalan. 

This way, I'm going to migrate some of my older posts (translating them into Spanish, if necessary) to the new blog, while I'd keep in vasco-caucasian (in English) those topics which I consider to be of interest to a wider audience. I'm sorry for the inconveniencies this might cause.

Regards,
Octavià  

02 September 2013

Basque otso 'wolf' (updated)

Basque otso 'wolf' apparently derives from Aquitanian OSSON, OXSON1, where XS probably reflects an apico-alveolar affricate like the one found in modern Basque. There're also the Iberian onomastic element ośon and the "Tartessian" toponym Osson-oba 'River of wolves', whose second member is probably an Italoid toponymic element (e.g. On-oba) cognate to Lithuanian upė2.

My colleague Miguel Carrasquer links this word to Berber *wVʃʃVn 'jackal', in turn linked to Egyptian wnʃ 'wolf' by Militarev. I regard this and other substrate loanwords as remnants of a Paleo-Berber language once spoken in the Iberian Peninsula. This would possibly be reflected in the distribution of Y-chromosome haplogroup E-M81, native to NW Africa but found also in some areas of the Iberian Peninsula (especially on the west), with a strong peak among Pasiegos of Cantabria, an ethnical group of trashumant shepherds3.

Distribution of Y-chromosome haplogroup E-M81
______________________
1 J. Gorrotxategi (1984): Estudio sobre la onomástica indígena de Aquitania, p. 250-251.
2 F. Villar (2000): Indoeuropeos y no indoeuropeos en la Hispania prerromana.
3 Attempts to explain this as a result of the Muslim conquest (8th century AD) can be dismissed.